As an early-career researcher in the process of completing my PhD, I am often reminded of the developing nature of practice-as-research within the academy. Using filmmaking as my primary research method, I have had to contend with the challenging task of performing this research during a national lockdown in Scotland.

For context, my proposed PhD project aims to explore how male intimacy is performed cinematically and how casting, scriptwriting and working with actors contributes to representations of male characters and their expression of homosocial intimacy between each other.

Part of the original research outline was to create a working space between director and actor which can reflect on the behavioural expectations of a patriarchal society and result in a transgressive performance of masculinity and intimacy between men. With the inability to work with actors physically during lockdown, I was challenged to continue my research without what I considered a key resource - access to other human beings!

Like many researchers in my position, I was forced to radically reconsider my data collection activities while isolated from others. Although I was able to make films with actors over video calling, I felt frustrated at the lack of physical contact and the cinematic control I was used to. Coming to terms with my finite resources, I decided to continue experimenting with myself as a simultaneous researcher and participant.

The decision to create a film that featured multiple versions of myself at the same time was the result of one of my supervisors comparing my work to photographer Cindy Sherman’s. The idea to represent different facets of myself led to me exploring what different actions reinforced my ideas of masculinity, leading to my short film Masculine Affirmation.

It was enjoyable getting to participate in this playful exercise and to be both critical and personal about the different pluralities of masculinity that I adhere to, especially ones which could be considered in conflict with each other. At the same time, there was technical rigour I had to adhere to in making this film, especially when it came to layering different performances of myself on top of each other in the manner of David Fincher’s The Social Network.

I consider this film a success in that it forced me to contemplate my ideas of ideal masculinity. However, rather than revel in being able to make a more traditional film again, I realised that the homosocial intimacy my project is centred around was entirely more present in previous projects where I worked with participants remotely, despite the lack of actors in a physical space.

The knowledge gained through my filmmaking experiences during lockdown will continue to be expanded upon and integrated into my future practice-as-research activities. Despite having little in the way of what I considered essential resources for my practice during lockdown, I was able to work creatively to make sure that my time alone was not only spent productively, but that it challenged me in ways that would not be possible outside of this pandemic.

The previous emphasis on physical intimacy in my project was confronted, and I have come to realise that real connections can still occur even in a digital space. The future of my doctoral research has been undoubtedly supported and shaped by these filmmaking activities, and I am excited to continue challenging my preconceptions of useful research in the uncertain but invigorating times ahead.

Andrew Rooke

Related Blog Posts

Transport themed pattern
QMU Annual Travel Survey

Every year the university conducts a travel survey, collecting commuting habits of staff and stud... read more

A group of young people, both black and white, wearing casual sports wear, sit in a classroom and are engaged in a friendly conversation.
Critical dialogue - developing confidence in young people

Critical dialogue is helping young Scots and Malawians develop confidence and gain empowerment.... read more

A small group of people talking, facing away from the camera, on a sunny day outside
Making for good

Making for good We are Amy Millar and Amy McCue - more commonly known on our course as “The Amy’s... read more

A small group of people talking, facing away from the camera, on a sunny day outside
A dyslexic student's advice for making a successful time of studies at QMU

“How to make the most of your studies?” is a question that is often asked. What are the best tech... read more

3 girls in winter jackets outside the Queen Margaret University Campus, Edinburgh
Top tips for open day

Prepare before you get to the University. Consider attending an open day event to find out what i... read more

QMU students playing jenga whilst others have tea and biscuits beside them
Top tips for halls

Moving away from home can be daunting whether you are undergraduate or a postgraduate. At Queen M... read more

Students queuing up to order at Maggie's Bar, the QMU student union bar and cafe
Freshers blog

My first day at QMU was a scary one, as I’m sure it was for everyone. Having only just moved from... read more

A busy street
Life as a mature student: why go to university?

For me higher education is about working towards achieving your potential to catapult you into th... read more

Students talking on the benches outside Queen Margaret University, Edinburgh
Queen Margaret university fresher’s week: 10 tips for student life

Top 10 Tips for student life read more

A small group of people talking, facing away from the camera, on a sunny day outside
University as a mature student

From where I started my academic journey, like many things in life, I have arrived at a very diff... read more